Horrible libertarian belief. Imagine you saved 10 years of hard earned money, and it loses 60% of your life-saving. China made money not by devalued it's currency. They made their money by being more competitive.
So you are advocating that Japan become a service-based economy over one that manufactures high-grade goods? Having a weak currency generally boosts exports but at a certain point it becomes damaging as it becomes really expensive to import the goods needed to make those exported products, considering Japan is not a resource-rich nation. Relying on tourism solely is not a good way to boost your economy as tourism fluctuates and can go up or down based on factors outside of a country's control.
the problem is japan not choose to be neutral but allow to choose western that colonise many country ,so stupid yeah if we think about it like they have another agenda that i cannot say ,so scare to see the most favourite asia country become like this ,hei japan also want to sell they people laa they are crazy money race like china
saya kata dalam bahasa sayalah ya awak terjemahkan sendiri ,walaupun yen lemah ia berkait dengan kelemahan pengurusan dan ekonomi jepun yang melemah kerana kurang mampu berdaya saing apatah lagi tindakna bodoh jepun bersaing dengan amerika dan china akan meburukkan keadaan jepun sepatutnya berada dipihak berkecuali tidak sokong mana mana negara ,jepun juga tak mampu bersaing dengan dua negara besar ekonomi yang mana penduduk dia lebih ramai dari jepun hanyalah sebuah negara kepualauan yang tak mampu saingi china dan amerika yang 5 kali lebih besar saiz ekonominya dari jepun ,jepun mampu saingi negara eropah korea dan asia tenggara ja itu lebih layak ,level jepun juga dah jatuh ke negara kelas kedua bukan lagi negara kelas pertama seperti negara kuasa besar dunia ,kedudukan jepun juga akan jatuh ditangga ke 8 menjelang 2090 yang mana banyak negara kuasa baru akan muncul menenggelamkan penguasaan ekonomi jepun jika jepun gagal selesaikan masalahnya dan jepun terpaksa ambil masa yang lebih lama untuk kembali berdaya saing dan kaya maju memintas beberapa negara kuasa baru menjelang 2300 ,sekarang ni jepun perlu naikkan sedikit nilai yennya bagi atasi masalah kos yang tinggi dan tetapkan semula dasar OPR mereka melebihi 1 peratus ,macam malaysia negara saya kadar dasar semalaman OPR meningkat stabil dari 1 peratus ke 3 peratus membuktikan ekonomi negara kami masih sihat panjang selepas zaman pandemik covid 19 berakhir ,jepun juga harus bangkit menguasai semula ekonomi sekitar tahun 2030 sehingga 2050 sebab jepun tak boleh bertahan lama menyaingi negara kuasa baru seperti indonesia ,india filipina dan vietnam yang mula membina kekayaan ekonomi mereka menyaingi jepun
walaupun begitu ia bukan sebab baik bagaimana jepun nak atasi maslaah ekonominya yang dah lama rosak akibat dari ketidakbijaksanaan pemerintah mereka , bayangkan dijepun mereke bekerja keras melebihi masa ditetapkan dan gajinya kekal rendah ia jelas tak adil tokkk ,ini melampau satu penindasan pekerja dijepun masih menghantui orang jepun memaksa mereka bekerja diluar negara jauh dari tekanan melampau negara mereka ,buktinya kami mendengar luahan hati orang jepun yang tinggal dinegara saya malaysia dia kata dimalaysia lebih baik berbanding dijepun semua benda mahal walaupun yen lemah ,ia hanya beri manfaat pada orang asing ,bukan pada orang jepun ,orang jepun juga bekerja belajar sehingga pandai tapi begini diperlakukan ,ia jelas tak adil laa orang putih ,kalau mereka nak gembira mereka akan bina ekonomi dinegara berpotensi besar seperti di malaysia amerika eropah ,mereka boleh melabur dinegara kesukaan mereka tanpa bergantung pada negara mereka yang sudah rosak ,dan kebanyakan orang muda jepun juga lebih suka belajar dan bekerja diluar negara berbanding dinegaranya yang banyak masalah sosial
In reality, the main beneficiaries of the weak yen are Japan's large corporations, while small and medium-sized enterprises (which make up 99% of Japanese companies and rely on domestic demand) gain relatively little. This raises concerns about widening inequality between those connected to large corporations and other social groups.
Guys, wake up please. Weak yen superstition is for those old Japanese ppl. At present, Japanese products are no longer as competitive as in their past. Ppl nowadays prefer iPhone, Samsung, made in china, but not Japanese products. Weak yen will not help to revive its country glory, it only makes Japan a poorer nation.
The only way Japan benefits is through tourism. That's it. In every other way, Japan loses out.
Imports are more expensive and Japan imports a lot, so ordinary people suffer. Wages will never rise at the same rate, eroding real incomes.
Besides gaining the opportunity to buy up Japanese companies on the cheap, foreign investors will dump/slow down buying of government debt causing the price to fall and the yield to rise. None of that is good for Japan, not it's companies being taken over and not the yield on its massive public debt rising.
This analysis by @BehindAsia is largely INACURATE because it overlooks several key issues facing the Japanese economy:
1) Aging Population & Immigration Policies The central challenge for Japan's economy is its rapidly aging population. With immigration policies that are far from open, the weak Yen only compounds Japan's difficulties. There aren't enough workers to sustain and grow the manufacturing sector, which limits the country's ability to compete in exports. Japan would need millions of immigrants to rejuvenate its declining industries, but the cheap Yen makes Japan far less attractive for potential foreign workers. Why would someone, for instance, leave a country like Mexico where wages are almost comparable to Japan's to navigate the cultural adjustments and strict work culture?
2) Tourism Won’t Be Enough The tourism sector also isn't the economic savior some might think. Japan faces the same labor shortage in this industry, meaning that only the luxury tourism segment—already long-established—can afford the higher wages. This is unlikely to significantly boost the economy. Moreover, Japan has a mixed attitude towards tourism; a substantial portion of the population is resistant, leading to challenges for new industry entrants. Strict regulations and licensing difficulties, as seen with Airbnb, only add to the barriers.
In short, Japan appears to be entering a downward spiral. Your video presents a narrow viewpoint and doesn't fully address the broader economic issues Japan faces.
Many large companies with overseas branches and Exporting companies have achieved record profits thanks to the weak yen. However, the current domestic economic situation is not that good due to rising commodity prices and people are reluctant to spend.
37 Comments
Do you think the yen's drop is going to boost Japan's economy?
i'm first
i'm second thou
3rd
If so, why did BOJ raise interest rate?
Is it cheaper to hire Japanese AV actresses?
Asia's people very hardworking
After the success of Weak Pound and Weak Dong, now we have Weak Yen!
This channel is very well informed and smart. Where are you getting your facts? 👍 😊
Horrible libertarian belief. Imagine you saved 10 years of hard earned money, and it loses 60% of your life-saving. China made money not by devalued it's currency. They made their money by being more competitive.
What a stupid take!
So you are advocating that Japan become a service-based economy over one that manufactures high-grade goods? Having a weak currency generally boosts exports but at a certain point it becomes damaging as it becomes really expensive to import the goods needed to make those exported products, considering Japan is not a resource-rich nation. Relying on tourism solely is not a good way to boost your economy as tourism fluctuates and can go up or down based on factors outside of a country's control.
why western love japan so much ,we asia people even dont know to to make japan realise they in wrong allies
the problem is japan not choose to be neutral but allow to choose western that colonise many country ,so stupid yeah if we think about it like they have another agenda that i cannot say ,so scare to see the most favourite asia country become like this ,hei japan also want to sell they people laa they are crazy money race like china
Eventhough Yen is cheap, It will not help Japan trading at all.
saya kata dalam bahasa sayalah ya awak terjemahkan sendiri ,walaupun yen lemah ia berkait dengan kelemahan pengurusan dan ekonomi jepun yang melemah kerana kurang mampu berdaya saing apatah lagi tindakna bodoh jepun bersaing dengan amerika dan china akan meburukkan keadaan jepun sepatutnya berada dipihak berkecuali tidak sokong mana mana negara ,jepun juga tak mampu bersaing dengan dua negara besar ekonomi yang mana penduduk dia lebih ramai dari jepun hanyalah sebuah negara kepualauan yang tak mampu saingi china dan amerika yang 5 kali lebih besar saiz ekonominya dari jepun ,jepun mampu saingi negara eropah korea dan asia tenggara ja itu lebih layak ,level jepun juga dah jatuh ke negara kelas kedua bukan lagi negara kelas pertama seperti negara kuasa besar dunia ,kedudukan jepun juga akan jatuh ditangga ke 8 menjelang 2090 yang mana banyak negara kuasa baru akan muncul menenggelamkan penguasaan ekonomi jepun jika jepun gagal selesaikan masalahnya dan jepun terpaksa ambil masa yang lebih lama untuk kembali berdaya saing dan kaya maju memintas beberapa negara kuasa baru menjelang 2300 ,sekarang ni jepun perlu naikkan sedikit nilai yennya bagi atasi masalah kos yang tinggi dan tetapkan semula dasar OPR mereka melebihi 1 peratus ,macam malaysia negara saya kadar dasar semalaman OPR meningkat stabil dari 1 peratus ke 3 peratus membuktikan ekonomi negara kami masih sihat panjang selepas zaman pandemik covid 19 berakhir ,jepun juga harus bangkit menguasai semula ekonomi sekitar tahun 2030 sehingga 2050 sebab jepun tak boleh bertahan lama menyaingi negara kuasa baru seperti indonesia ,india filipina dan vietnam yang mula membina kekayaan ekonomi mereka menyaingi jepun
They have a lousy software ecosystem. Talk about the effect of their pathetic software skills.
They have a lousy software ecosystem. Talk about the effect of their pathetic software skills.
walaupun begitu ia bukan sebab baik bagaimana jepun nak atasi maslaah ekonominya yang dah lama rosak akibat dari ketidakbijaksanaan pemerintah mereka , bayangkan dijepun mereke bekerja keras melebihi masa ditetapkan dan gajinya kekal rendah ia jelas tak adil tokkk ,ini melampau satu penindasan pekerja dijepun masih menghantui orang jepun memaksa mereka bekerja diluar negara jauh dari tekanan melampau negara mereka ,buktinya kami mendengar luahan hati orang jepun yang tinggal dinegara saya malaysia dia kata dimalaysia lebih baik berbanding dijepun semua benda mahal walaupun yen lemah ,ia hanya beri manfaat pada orang asing ,bukan pada orang jepun ,orang jepun juga bekerja belajar sehingga pandai tapi begini diperlakukan ,ia jelas tak adil laa orang putih ,kalau mereka nak gembira mereka akan bina ekonomi dinegara berpotensi besar seperti di malaysia amerika eropah ,mereka boleh melabur dinegara kesukaan mereka tanpa bergantung pada negara mereka yang sudah rosak ,dan kebanyakan orang muda jepun juga lebih suka belajar dan bekerja diluar negara berbanding dinegaranya yang banyak masalah sosial
but for this time japan really ii not smart to handle they economy la they should be critism like western economy
In reality, the main beneficiaries of the weak yen are Japan's large corporations, while small and medium-sized enterprises (which make up 99% of Japanese companies and rely on domestic demand) gain relatively little. This raises concerns about widening inequality between those connected to large corporations and other social groups.
The highest YEN not good fr Japanese Economy .Means Japanese Export to Weakness Country eg Country like Msia Thai n Indonesia
Cheap yen is good for Japan economy but bad for Japanese people.
Guys, wake up please. Weak yen superstition is for those old Japanese ppl. At present, Japanese products are no longer as competitive as in their past. Ppl nowadays prefer iPhone, Samsung, made in china, but not Japanese products. Weak yen will not help to revive its country glory, it only makes Japan a poorer nation.
The only way Japan benefits is through tourism. That's it. In every other way, Japan loses out.
Imports are more expensive and Japan imports a lot, so ordinary people suffer. Wages will never rise at the same rate, eroding real incomes.
Besides gaining the opportunity to buy up Japanese companies on the cheap, foreign investors will dump/slow down buying of government debt causing the price to fall and the yield to rise. None of that is good for Japan, not it's companies being taken over and not the yield on its massive public debt rising.
This video is simply nonsense.
This is one of the staggeringly retarded takes I’ve ever heard.
We are still working and nothing chance many years. My husband work in Nippon steel (Toyota) . The prices rises higher only. Japan.😮
This analysis by @BehindAsia is largely INACURATE because it overlooks several key issues facing the Japanese economy:
1) Aging Population & Immigration Policies
The central challenge for Japan's economy is its rapidly aging population. With immigration policies that are far from open, the weak Yen only compounds Japan's difficulties. There aren't enough workers to sustain and grow the manufacturing sector, which limits the country's ability to compete in exports. Japan would need millions of immigrants to rejuvenate its declining industries, but the cheap Yen makes Japan far less attractive for potential foreign workers. Why would someone, for instance, leave a country like Mexico where wages are almost comparable to Japan's to navigate the cultural adjustments and strict work culture?
2) Tourism Won’t Be Enough
The tourism sector also isn't the economic savior some might think. Japan faces the same labor shortage in this industry, meaning that only the luxury tourism segment—already long-established—can afford the higher wages. This is unlikely to significantly boost the economy. Moreover, Japan has a mixed attitude towards tourism; a substantial portion of the population is resistant, leading to challenges for new industry entrants. Strict regulations and licensing difficulties, as seen with Airbnb, only add to the barriers.
In short, Japan appears to be entering a downward spiral. Your video presents a narrow viewpoint and doesn't fully address the broader economic issues Japan faces.
Now 193
Graduated from primary school.
円安は、基本的には、良くないです。然し、日本の良いところとしては、人口減少によるロボット導入が他の国に比べてかなりしやすいことです。他の国は、移民が入っていたり、人口が増加しているので、中々ロボット導入が進みません。そして、AIについても日本は、他の国と比べ、宗教の力が弱く、とてもデジタルに積極的なところです。日本は、今、かなり良くなる為の転換点にいます。これから、アフリカ諸国の奴らがある程度お金持ちになってくると食料争奪戦になるが、日本は、水大国で、エネルギーについても、三菱重工業が核融合発電の研究を着実に進めています。日本の将来は、人口減少によるAI&ロボット先進国になるでしょう。そして、その頃には、もう少し、円安になっているので、労働力をロボットで補い、輸出超大学の復活が来るでしょう。
Nope. Not at all. You’ e got this wrong in every way possible.
Many large companies with overseas branches and Exporting companies have achieved record profits thanks to the weak yen. However, the current domestic economic situation is not that good due to rising commodity prices and people are reluctant to spend.
日本のメーカーはもはや日本で製造してない
円安はほとんど害にしかならない
30年以上、食料品なんかの物価が同じだった。
子供の頃に食べていたお菓子が最近まで同じ値段で売っていた。
お金の価値が減らないから、子供ですらお小遣いを銀行口座に貯金していた。
お金が有っても日本人は貯金しちゃうから、消費させるのが大変なんだよ。
For export driven economies devaluation is a super weapon — nominal GDP is an imaginary number.
「日本は移民で解決だー」でもね
電車やレストランでスマホ通話してないんだな
クルマがいないのに信号を守るなんて効率悪い～
何で街にゴミ箱がないんだ～ でもゴミ落ちてないよね
列に並ぶ日本人すごい～
クラクションの音聞こえないね
公共の場所はどこも静かだな あ でも ドンキやスーパーの音は耳に残るけどね
落書きが無いよな～
入れ墨はアートなのにどこが悪いんだ
小さな子供が一人で電車に乗ってるよ～ やば～い
お客様は神様を字面道理にとらないでね あくまで生活を豊かにする便宜的なものだから
なんで英語が通じないんだ～
店の外に売り物を並べてるよ 大丈夫かな
なんで警察は外国人ばかり職質するんだ～(気のせいですから)
なんで電車で外国人を避けるんだ～(気のせいですから)
レストランの予約を連絡なしでキャンセルしないでね
ゴミを捨てて ゴミ拾いの仕事を作ってやってるとか 屁理屈を言わないでね
まあいろいろあるけど 頭に浮かんだこれらのことに疑問を持つなら 移民は遠慮してね